Because neither profile can connect to Xbox Live on the same Xbox One, first check Xbox service status and then test the console’s network connection; Home Xbox and Game Pass sharing cannot resolve a console-wide sign-in failure.
1. Check Xbox Network status
Open the official Xbox Status page and check Account & profile / Sign-in. The page also reports multiplayer, Store, and other Xbox service incidents.^1^
- If an outage is shown: wait for Microsoft to mark it resolved, then try both profiles again.
- If no outage is shown: continue with the console test.
2. Test the Xbox One connection
On the Xbox One:
- Press the Xbox button.
- Open Profile & system > Settings > General > Network settings.
- Select Test network connection.
- Note the exact message or error code.
If the test fails:
- Fully shut down the Xbox by holding its power button for about 10 seconds.
- Unplug the Xbox and router/modem briefly.
- Reconnect the router first and wait until internet service returns.
- Reconnect and start the Xbox, then run Test network connection again.
If possible, also test with an Ethernet cable or a phone hotspot. If one of those works, the problem is with the normal router or internet connection rather than either Xbox account.
3. If the network test succeeds but profiles still cannot sign in
Remove and add one profile as a test:
- Open Profile & system > Settings > Account > Remove accounts.
- Remove one affected profile only.
- Restart the Xbox.
- Press the Xbox button and select Profile & system > Add or switch > Add new.
- Sign in using that profile’s Microsoft account credentials.
Do not remove a profile unless its email address and password are known. If the account uses passwordless sign-in and the console does not complete authentication, manage its sign-in credentials and try again; unresolved account sign-in problems should be taken to Xbox Support.^2^
4. Check for enforcement only if an account warning appears
An account or device suspension can prevent Xbox Live access. If the console displays an enforcement or suspension message, review the enforcement status and submit a case review where available.^3^
Because both profiles fail on one console, do not assume an account suspension unless the console or enforcement page specifically reports one.
5. Game Pass Ultimate and Home Xbox
Game Pass Ultimate is associated with the subscribing Xbox account and supports Xbox One consoles.^4^ Home Xbox settings concern access to games and subscription benefits; they do not explain why neither profile can connect to Xbox Live.
After sign-in works, verify the console is the subscriber’s Home Xbox if the second profile needs shared access:
Profile & system > Settings > General > Personalization > My home Xbox.
6. Last resort: reset or contact support
If the network test passes and re-adding a profile fails, contact Xbox Support and provide:
- Xbox One model
- Network-test result
- Exact sign-in message and error code
- Whether the account can sign in on the Microsoft account website
- Whether another network or hotspot worked
A factory reset should be a last resort. Back up the console settings first, then use Xbox’s documented reset procedure.^5^ A reset can remove local accounts and settings, so do not perform it until the account credentials are available.
References
- XBOX Status | XBOX Support
- Xbox can’t sign in with passwordless account - Microsoft Q&A
- Learn why your account was banned or suspended from Xbox Live | Microsoft Support
- Usage rules for Digital Goods (“Rules”) | Microsoft Support
- Before you recycle, sell, or gift your Xbox or Windows PC | Microsoft Support