Using the New Outlook for Mac for personal email and calendar
Hi @Susan W
Since the problem started immediately after the macOS 27.2.1 update and resetting the account did not help, I would first check whether Pin is unavailable everywhere or only in the current folder or view.
Please note that this is a user-to-user support forum. Moderators, contributors including external Microsoft employees cannot directly intervene in Microsoft product features or access back-end systems. Our role is limited to providing technical guidance on reported issues, requests, or ideas only.
Please open the regular Inbox, clear any search or filter, and select one message directly from the message list. Then check whether Message > Pin is available from the macOS menu bar. If the menu command works but the toolbar button remains unavailable, select the three-dot menu on the toolbar and choose Customize Toolbar to remove and add the Pin command again.
If Pin remains grayed out for every message in the Inbox, please record the Outlook version from Outlook > About Outlook, then use Help > Feedback > Report a Problem. Include that the issue began after macOS 27.2.1 and that the pinned messages disappeared at the same time. This will provide Outlook diagnostics to Microsoft and help determine whether the update introduced a compatibility issue.
For additional assistance with a personal account, you can also use Help > Contact Support in Outlook for Mac. Microsoft recommends this route for Outlook for Mac issues that remain unresolved.
Thank you for your understanding.