Changing between multiple Microsoft Teams accounts within the app or browser
The two email addresses might be connected to the same Microsoft account. For example, one could be the main address and the other an alias.
That could explain why Microsoft keeps showing a different address, but it doesn't confirm why the invitation is failing.
I'd try this first:
- Sign out of Microsoft accounts in your browser.
- Open a private browser window.
- Open the original invitation email and use the invitation link, rather than opening Teams directly.
Microsoft specifically says that when an email alias is involved, the user needs to redeem the invitation through the email link.
If it still fails, I'd ask your IT team to check the guest account in Microsoft Entra. They should compare the invited email address with the account's Email, Other emails, and sign-in identity.
They should also check the full error details rather than deleting and recreating the guest again.
If the invitation was previously accepted using the wrong account, the administrator can use Reset redemption status to let you accept it again. This keeps the existing guest account and its group memberships.
I wouldn't remove an email alias or change the invitation address until your IT team confirms which account Microsoft is actually using.
Microsoft references: