This behavior matches the documented limitation of the Surface Thunderbolt 4 Dock with non-Thunderbolt host connections.
- The Surface Thunderbolt 4 Dock supports two 4K external displays at up to 60 Hz when the host device is connected over Thunderbolt 4/USB4 and the device/display support it.
- When the dock is connected using USB-C instead of USB4/Thunderbolt 4, it supports only one 4K external display at up to 60 Hz.
- A Microsoft Q&A resolution for the same symptom states that if the computer is not Thunderbolt 4-compatible, the Surface Thunderbolt 4 Dock will use only one external monitor, regardless of monitor resolution.
That explains the test results:
- Snapdragon Surface Pro + both monitors through the dock: only one monitor is detected because the dock is operating as a USB-C display connection rather than full Thunderbolt 4 multi-display.
- Snapdragon Surface Pro + one monitor on dock + one directly on the device: both monitors work because only one display is being driven through the dock.
- Intel Surface Pro 9 + both monitors through the dock: both monitors work because that setup can use the dock’s full dual-display capability when connected with the required host support.
Resolution:
- For the Snapdragon Surface Pro, use one monitor through the dock and the second monitor directly on the Surface.
- If both monitors must connect through a single dock, use a host/dock combination that supports the dock’s USB4/Thunderbolt 4 dual-display mode.
- If the goal is formal product feedback or escalation, use Get Help or the Surface app for technical support. For work or school devices, contact the organization’s IT helpdesk or admin.