Contact your school’s IT help desk and ask them to reset your MFA methods and require MFA re-registration, because the alternate sign-in option is returning you to the unavailable Authenticator method.
What to request
Send the help desk this message:
I replaced my phone and no longer have access to the Microsoft Authenticator registration on my old phone. “Can’t use Authenticator” returns me to Authenticator, and I have no other verification method available. Please reset my MFA methods and require me to re-register MFA on my new phone.
This is a school-managed account, so Microsoft forum users cannot change its authentication settings. A matching school-account case confirms that the institution’s IT team must perform the reset when the account is caught in this loop.^1^
Steps for your school administrator
An Authentication Administrator should:
- Sign in to the Microsoft Entra admin center.
- Go to Entra ID → Users.
- Select your user account.
- Select Authentication methods.
- Select Require re-register MFA and confirm.
This removes the existing Authenticator and related MFA methods so that you are prompted to configure a new method at your next sign-in.^2^
After the reset:
- Install Microsoft Authenticator on the new phone.
- Sign in to the school account again from a computer or browser.
- When prompted to set up security information, choose Microsoft Authenticator.
- Scan the displayed QR code with the new phone.
- Complete the test approval and confirm that sign-in works.
Reinstalling or restoring Authenticator alone will not restore a work or school account’s credentials. Only the account name can be restored; the account must be signed in and registered again on the new device.^3^
If the school has a student help desk, identity/access team, or Microsoft 365 administrator, contact that group rather than Microsoft consumer-account support.
References
- Please help me reset my account in Authenticator, I need to access my school account!! - Microsoft Q&A
- Manage user authentication methods for Microsoft Entra multifactor authentication
- Transfer Microsoft Authenticator account entries to a new phone