We are developing a healthcare practice management application using Microsoft Entra External ID (customer tenant).
Current architecture:
- Public Windows desktop application using MSAL.
Delegated access to a protected Web API.
Microsoft Entra External ID as the existing identity provider.
Security Defaults are enabled and must remain enabled.
Sensitive administrative actions require an additional, recent strong authentication confirmation.
The backend must verify this confirmation server-side.
Verified problem:
A matching Microsoft sign-in log shows successful password-only authentication ("Password in the cloud"). Conditional Access was not applied.
The corresponding API access token did not contain the required amr and auth_time claims. Our backend therefore correctly refuses the protected operation with HTTP 403.
The exact first server-side rejection branch was not recorded, but the absence of fresh MFA is confirmed.
We have investigated authentication contexts and MSAL claims challenges. However, our tenant currently has no configured authentication contexts or Conditional Access policies.
Microsoft indicates that configuring Conditional Access policies requires disabling Security Defaults. We do not want to weaken our existing tenant security.
Our questions:
Is there a Microsoft-supported way to require fresh, action-specific MFA or passkey authentication while keeping Security Defaults enabled in an Entra External ID customer tenant?
Can our backend reliably verify that strong authentication occurred within the previous five minutes specifically for the protected operation, rather than accepting an earlier authenticated session?
Which signed token claims or supported mechanisms provide verifiable proof of the authentication method, freshness, user identity, application and resource binding?
Would passkeys using Windows Hello be suitable? What enrollment prerequisites apply, and can this work without purchasing additional hardware or requiring a second smartphone?
Can the same security architecture support both the Windows desktop client and a browser-based PWA?
Is a solution available without additional licensing costs or disabling Security Defaults?
If this is not supported with Security Defaults enabled, please confirm the limitation and identify the officially supported alternatives, including their licensing and security implications.
We want to retain Microsoft Entra External ID and our existing backend authorization controls. We are not looking for a custom authentication system or a reduction in security.
Official Microsoft documentation references would be particularly helpful.We are developing a healthcare practice management application using Microsoft Entra External ID (customer tenant).
Current architecture:
Public Windows desktop application using MSAL.
Delegated access to a protected Web API.
Microsoft Entra External ID as the existing identity provider.
Security Defaults are enabled and must remain enabled.
Sensitive administrative actions require an additional, recent strong authentication confirmation.
The backend must verify this confirmation server-side.
Verified problem:
A matching Microsoft sign-in log shows successful password-only authentication ("Password in the cloud"). Conditional Access was not applied.
The corresponding API access token did not contain the required amr and auth_time claims. Our backend therefore correctly refuses the protected operation with HTTP 403.
The exact first server-side rejection branch was not recorded, but the absence of fresh MFA is confirmed.
We have investigated authentication contexts and MSAL claims challenges. However, our tenant currently has no configured authentication contexts or Conditional Access policies.
Microsoft indicates that configuring Conditional Access policies requires disabling Security Defaults. We do not want to weaken our existing tenant security.
Our questions:
Is there a Microsoft-supported way to require fresh, action-specific MFA or passkey authentication while keeping Security Defaults enabled in an Entra External ID customer tenant?
Can our backend reliably verify that strong authentication occurred within the previous five minutes specifically for the protected operation, rather than accepting an earlier authenticated session?
Which signed token claims or supported mechanisms provide verifiable proof of the authentication method, freshness, user identity, application and resource binding?
Would passkeys using Windows Hello be suitable? What enrollment prerequisites apply, and can this work without purchasing additional hardware or requiring a second smartphone?
Can the same security architecture support both the Windows desktop client and a browser-based PWA?
Is a solution available without additional licensing costs or disabling Security Defaults?
If this is not supported with Security Defaults enabled, please confirm the limitation and identify the officially supported alternatives, including their licensing and security implications.
We want to retain Microsoft Entra External ID and our existing backend authorization controls. We are not looking for a custom authentication system or a reduction in security.
Official Microsoft documentation references would be particularly helpful.