Using Outlook for iOS in business environments for email and scheduling
Good day Maddie,
Just to gently clarify before going any further, this forum is separate from Microsoft Support. I don’t have the ability to access or investigate individual accounts or escalate the issue directly Microsoft Support because this is a user‑to‑user support forum.
This issue is most likely occurring because Microsoft Authenticator was registered on your previous phone. For work accounts, the Authenticator credentials aren't transferred to a new phone through backup. The account must be registered again on the new device.
Situation 1: If you still have access to your old phone
If you still have access to your old phone and Microsoft Authenticator is working on it, use the old phone to approve the sign-in request or obtain the verification code.
On your work computer, go to the Security info page.
Select Add sign-in method > Select Microsoft Authenticator > Follow the instructions to register your new phone.
Confirm that sign-in approval works on the new phone before removing the old phone from your Security info page or erasing it.
Situation 2: If your old phone is no longer available
Because this is a work account, the MFA settings are managed by your organization's IT administrator. The fastest way forward is to contact your organization's IT support team and explain: "I am stuck in a login loop between Outlook and the Microsoft Authenticator app. I cannot get the code to sign in."
Note: In case you do not know who is your IT admin, kindly refer to this article: How do I find my Microsoft 365 admin? - Microsoft Support
This is a standard request and your organization’s IT team should be able to assist you with it. You can also share the steps in this Microsoft article for them so they can help reset your MFA settings for you: Manage user authentication methods for Microsoft Entra multifactor authentication.
Once your IT administrator has reset your authentication settings, sign in again and follow the prompts to register your phone number or Microsoft Authenticator on your current device. After that, consider adding a backup verification method, such as an alternate email address, so you still have a way to access your account if you lose access to your primary verification method in the future.
Additional information is available in the following resource: How to add your accounts to Microsoft Authenticator | Microsoft Support
I wish I could help more directly, but as a fellow user in this community, providing these steps is the best support I can offer. I hope your admin can help you regain access to your school account soon.
If you have any questions, please don’t hesitate to reach out at any time.
Thank you for your patience and understanding.