how to fix external hard drive that topped to show in the computer it looks like file are lost?

MOIEE FRMAN 0 Reputation points
2026-11-05T21:26:10.6366667+00:00

When I go to disc manager it shows there a unknown disk with a red dot on it I want to work on it it pops up a window that I need to initialize a disk first ad it ask me 2 options or MBR or GPT so which one I select?

Windows for home | Windows 11 | Devices and drivers
0 comments No comments

2 answers

Sort by: Newest
  1. Manoel Barros 23,275 Reputation points Independent Advisor
    2026-11-05T23:08:32.0633333+00:00

    Hi!

    You should not initialize the disk, as the AI ​​suggested, because you could lose all your data.

    The disk should be initialized automatically by Windows when you connect it. If it did not initialize on its own, it means there is a fault with the disk, the enclosure, or the USB cable.

    Please perform all the tests below and send me the results.

    1. Disconnect the external drive and try connecting it to different USB ports.
    2. Replace the external drive's cable.
    3. Place your hand on the external drive to see if you can feel any vibration (the drive contains a spinning disk, which should be rotating when connected to the computer). Note that with some external drive enclosures, it may not be possible to feel this vibration, but it is still worth checking.
    4. If the enclosure has an indicator light, check whether it is on, and whether it is flashing or steady.
    5. Listen for any unusual noises coming from the external drive, such as parts knocking against each other.
    6. Finally, connect the drive to your computer and check its health using third-party software. Download CrystalDiskInfo from the Microsoft Store (via the link below), open the program, and send me a screenshot or a photo.

    https://apps.microsoft.com/detail/xp8k4rgx25g3gm?hl=en-us

    DISCLAIMER: This program is not from Microsoft, but it is a reliable program for checking the health and performance of your hard drive.

    Was this answer helpful?

    0 comments No comments

  2. AI answer

    2026-11-05T21:26:47.54+00:00

    Do not select MBR or GPT if this external drive previously contained files—cancel the Initialize Disk window, because initialization and subsequent partitioning or formatting can make the existing data inaccessible. Initialization is intended for a new, empty disk; formatting destroys data on the partition.^1^

    “Unknown” or “Not Initialized” does not necessarily mean the files are gone. Windows may be unable to read the disk signature or partition information because of corruption, a connection problem, or failing hardware.^2^

    Try these non-destructive checks

    1. Cancel the initialization prompt.
      • Do not create a New Simple Volume, format the disk, or delete anything.
      • Avoid running chkdsk at this stage; the disk has no accessible drive letter, and the priority is recovering files without writing changes.
    2. Check whether the disk is only Offline.
      • Right-click Start → Disk Management.
      • Find the external disk by its capacity.
      • If its status says Offline, right-click the disk label on the left and select Online.
      • If it then displays a Healthy partition but no letter, right-click that partition → Change Drive Letter and Paths → Add. It should then appear in File Explorer.^2^
    3. Refresh and test the connection.
      • In Disk Management, select Action → Rescan Disks.
      • Connect the drive directly to another USB port, not through a hub.
      • Try another compatible USB cable.
      • If the enclosure has its own power supply, shut it down, reconnect its power, and restart it.
      • Test the drive on another computer.^2^
    4. Check hardware detection.
      • Right-click Start → Device Manager → Disk drives.
      • Look for the external drive or a device showing an exclamation mark.
      • Open its Properties and note the device-status error, if any.

    If it remains Unknown or Not Initialized

    Use data-recovery software that can scan a physical disk without requiring a drive letter, and save recovered files to a different drive. Do not recover them back onto the affected disk. A closely matching Windows 11 case likewise recommends recovery before initialization or formatting when an existing external drive appears as unallocated or not initialized.^3^

    If the drive:

    • makes clicking or grinding sounds,
    • repeatedly disconnects,
    • reports the wrong capacity,
    • is not detected on another PC, or
    • contains irreplaceable files,

    stop repeatedly powering or scanning it and contact a professional data-recovery service. Failure on another PC indicates that the drive or enclosure, rather than Windows, is likely the problem.^2^

    When to choose GPT or MBR

    Only proceed if the drive is new/empty, or after the files have been recovered and you accept erasing/recreating its storage layout:

    • GPT: Preferred for modern Windows computers; more robust and supports volumes larger than 2 TB.
    • MBR: Mainly for compatibility with older computers and operating systems.^4^

    For an empty external drive used with Windows 11, select GPT, initialize it, right-click the resulting Unallocated space, select New Simple Volume, assign a drive letter, and format it. Do not perform these steps while trying to recover the old files.


    References

    1. Disk Management in Windows | Microsoft Support
    2. Troubleshoot Disk Management
    3. I have a Noontec hard drive that isn't recognised on W11 file manager. How can I access it to determine what data exists there> - Microsoft Q&A
    4. Initialize new disks
    AI-generated content may be incorrect. Read our transparency notes for more information.

    Was this answer helpful?

Your answer

Answers can be marked as 'Accepted' by the question author and 'Recommended' by moderators, which helps users know the answer solved the author's problem.