Organizing and accessing contact information in Outlook.com
This behavior matches a service-side issue in Outlook on the web rather than a problem with the contacts themselves.
Based on the described symptoms:
- individual contacts are still present
- contact lists are missing or fail with “Something went wrong”
- removing contacts from lists fails
- creating a new contact list also fails
That points to the web contacts experience failing, not to the underlying contacts being deleted.
What can be confirmed from Outlook on the web:
- Open People.
- Select All contact lists or Your contact lists.
- If a list opens normally, contacts can be removed by selecting the list, choosing Edit, selecting the x next to the name or email address, and then selecting Save.
- A contact can also be removed from a list by selecting the contact, choosing Add to list, selecting the X next to the list name, and closing the pane.
In this case, those normal management actions are already failing with the same error, so the practical next step is support escalation.
If this is an organizational Microsoft 365 account:
- Ask the Microsoft 365 administrator to open a support ticket from Microsoft 365 Admin Center > Support > Help & Support.
- This type of Outlook on the web Contacts/People issue can require backend review.
If this is an Outlook.com account:
- Use Outlook.com support from the Help menu or the Outlook.com support entry points.
- If self-help does not resolve it, use the Still need help? option to contact support.
If access to the lists returns, the supported ways to remove people are:
- People > All contact lists > select the list > Edit > select x next to the person > Save.
- People > select the contact > Add to list > select X next to the list name.