The whole idea of backing up is to store your data outside the computer.
If your backup destination is inside the computer, and the computer becomes inaccessible, your backup is also inaccessible.
This browser is no longer supported.
Upgrade to Microsoft Edge to take advantage of the latest features, security updates, and technical support.
I purchased a large spinning disk drive to use for various backup/sharing purposes and I want to be able to have windows backup -- ideally with file history -- from my primary SSD to this drive. However, apparently since it's an 'internal drive' windows won't recognize it as an option for file history and since it's a local drive I can't select it via network share option in the control panel File History section.
Hopefully, I'm just confused because I really resent the idea that my OS is going to decide what I can and can't use my drives for based on how they are connected. That's the point of abstracting drives as block devices. Am I being an idiot? Or is there some special fancy registry edit/powershell command to trick windows 11 into seeing my internal drive as an acceptable location to store file history to?
OS: Windows 11 Pro
Drives: C: (boot) NVMe SSD, D: larger internal spinning metal drive.
P.S. Yes, I saw a few similar questions on the site but they all either seemed to trail off, suggest making sure the drive isn't part of a library (it isn't) or were specific to earlier versions of windows. Note that I have backup to onedrive enabled and I wish to keep that enabled (and enable a local backup/file history as well) which seems to foreclose any other backup options in the settings app.
Locked Question. This question was migrated from the Microsoft Support Community. You can vote on whether it's helpful, but you can't add comments or replies or follow the question.
The whole idea of backing up is to store your data outside the computer.
If your backup destination is inside the computer, and the computer becomes inaccessible, your backup is also inaccessible.
Hi,
Windows 11 restricts File History backups to external drives or network locations by design, but there are workarounds to use internal drives. Here's how to bypass this limitation:
1. Network Share Workaround
Create a network share for your internal backup drive:
2. Registry Edit
Force Windows to recognize internal drives:
textWindows Registry Editor Version 5.00
[HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\FileHistory]
"LocalStoresAllowed"=dword:00000001
Create this REG_DWORD value (set to 1) to enable local drive support
3. Library Inclusion Method
For specific folders:
4. XML Configuration Hack
Manually edit File History settings:
%UserProfile%\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\FileHistory\Configuration\Config1.xmlImportant Notes
While Windows 11's restrictions seem arbitrary, these solutions leverage its existing framework to maintain backup flexibility. The registry edit method provides the most seamless integration, while network sharing offers better compatibility with future updates
Thank you very much Summit.
Sage,
All backup is a balance between convenience, cost and security. Hence why I'm backing up my documents and other important files to onedrive. But, I've dealt with enough data loss in my life that I want a larger faster backup for things like my large zotero library, videos being edited and various large models/datasets my wife is training/gathering (and some game saves that don't autosync).
Using an external drive only adds a trivial amount of safety. The most common forms of data loss (idiocy and malware) don't care if your drive is inside the case using SATA, plugged into a USB/thunderbolt port or downstairs on the network as long as your computer has write authority and it's most unusual these days to have data corruption because of a failure at the physical signal level rather than the logical level.
As far as other likely causes of data loss such as spilling **** on my computer, fire, theft or natural disaster it really doesn't matter if the disk sits inside the computer case, next to it and only a little if it's downstairs. Obviously, if cost was no object I'd have purchased a NAS and configured a redundant raid array but it isn't.