Using New Outlook on Windows for professional communication and productivity
Hi,
Yes, User B can see a signature that User A saved for the shared mailbox. Another team reported this exact behavior on Microsoft Q&A after both users added the shared mailbox as an account in new Outlook. Each could see the signatures the other had saved, and changing the mailbox’s default signature affected both users. Microsoft’s support articles confirm that signatures are configured for the account selected under Settings > Accounts > Signatures. I couldn’t find a Microsoft Support article that specifies where those signatures are stored or guarantees what every delegate will see across different mailbox setups.
It matters where User A selects the signature. Choosing one from Message > Signature while composing inserts it into that email only. Changing the default under Settings > Accounts > Signatures is a separate action. It was the change in Settings that affected both users in the reported case.
Classic Outlook can behave differently. If each person uses a signature stored in their own Windows profile, they can each insert their own signature when sending from the shared address. Classic Outlook for Microsoft 365 also supports roaming signatures, so the comparison depends on how the signatures were configured.
If you need each person’s sign-off to stay private in Outlook’s signature menu, I couldn’t find a documented setting that makes a signature saved under the shared mailbox visible only to its creator. With your current setup, each sender can paste their own sign-off into the message. There’s also a documented option if your team accesses the mailbox as a shared folder: each user can save their sign-off as a text snippet in My Templates and insert it manually. Microsoft says those templates are private to the user in that setup. If the mailbox has been added as a full account, templates created there can also be viewed and edited by colleagues who open it the same way.
Official Microsoft Support articles
- Manage shared mailbox settings in new Outlook
- How to add and change an email signature in Outlook
- Create email templates in Outlook — see “Template availability in shared mailboxes”
Related community report with the two users’ observations: Move from Outlook to New Outlook, signatures error