Configuring preferences and options in Outlook.com
Hi Ryan, thank you for sharing. Did you make sure all the details in the Microsoft account recovery form are correct, including your old email, a current contact email, previous passwords, and any linked phone numbers?
Microsoft only supports recovery through this form at account.live.com/acsr, and providing as much accurate information as possible gives the best chance to regain access. Check your contact email, including spam, for any response from Microsoft after submission.