Hi Store q21,
You are still receiving reaction notifications, which suggests that the reactions feature is enabled for your Microsoft 365 account. The issue may be limited to how the reaction button is being displayed in Classic Outlook rather than the feature being disabled entirely.
To help narrow down the cause, please try the following steps:
- Check Outlook on the web : Sign in to Outlook on the web and open the same email. If the reaction button is available there, the issue is likely specific to the Classic Outlook desktop client.
- Update Outlook : In Outlook, go to File > Office Account > Update Options > Update Now, install any available updates, and then restart Outlook.
- Test with other email messages : Some messages may have reactions disabled by the sender or through an Exchange Online mail flow rule, which can prevent the reaction button from appearing on those specific messages.
- Start Outlook in Safe Mode : Press Windows + R, type
outlook.exe /safe, and press Enter. If the reaction button reappears, an Outlook add-in may be interfering with the feature. You can then disable add-ins via File > Options > Add-ins > COM Add-ins > Go and test again.

- Create a new Outlook profile : Close Outlook, then navigate to Control Panel > Mail > Show Profiles > Add. Create a new profile, configure your account, and check whether the reaction button is available there.
For reference, reactions are supported for work or school accounts with eligible Microsoft 365 subscriptions and are available across supported Outlook clients, including Outlook for Windows: Microsoft Support: Reactions in Outlook
If the reaction button is missing in both Outlook on the web and Classic Outlook for all messages, I recommend contacting your IT administrator to verify whether any organizational policy or mail flow rule has recently been implemented that could affect reactions. If the issue is isolated to Classic Outlook and persists after the above troubleshooting steps, your administrator may need to open a support case with Microsoft and provide the Outlook build information from File > Office Account > About Outlook.
You may also refer to the Microsoft 365 support guide for instructions on opening a support request:
Get support - Microsoft 365 admin | Microsoft Learn
I hope these suggestions point you in the right direction. If you need any clarification or would like to share the results of your testing, please don't hesitate to reply.