Test with an address that has not previously emailed this mailbox during the current Out-of-Office period, because Outlook sends only one automatic reply to each sender until the OOF state or message is changed.^1^
Since the same failure occurs in desktop Outlook and Outlook on the web, focus on the mailbox and Exchange mail flow rather than reinstalling or repairing the desktop application.
Isolate the failure
- Send one message from a different internal mailbox that has not tested previously.
- Send another from a new external address.
- Ensure both messages arrive in the Inbox rather than Junk. Messages classified as spam and delivered to Junk do not generate automatic replies.^1^
- Record which result applies:
- Neither sender receives a reply: check mailbox forwarding and OOF rules.
- Internal works, external fails: check external-audience and remote-domain settings.
- A new sender works, but a previous sender does not: this is the expected one-reply-per-sender behavior.
Have the Microsoft 365 administrator check forwarding first
SMTP forwarding can prevent OOF replies from being generated. An administrator should run:
Get-Mailbox -Identity [Email] |
Format-List DeliverToMailboxAndForward,
ForwardingAddress,
ForwardingSmtpAddress
If forwarding is enabled but no longer required:
Set-Mailbox -Identity [Email] `
-ForwardingAddress $null `
-ForwardingSmtpAddress $null
If forwarding must remain enabled, retain delivery to the original mailbox so that the incoming message triggers OOF:
Set-Mailbox -Identity [Email] `
-DeliverToMailboxAndForward $true
Microsoft documents forwarding—and transport rules that redirect messages away from the mailbox—as causes of automatic replies not being triggered.^2^
The administrator should also open Exchange admin center → Mail flow → Rules and check for rules that redirect messages addressed to this mailbox. Do not remove an organization-wide rule without assessing its impact; disable only the applicable forwarding rule for a controlled test.
If only external replies fail
The administrator should check:
- Exchange admin center → Mail flow → Remote domains
- Whether automatic replies are enabled for the default or recipient-specific remote domain
- Whether
AllowedOOFType permits external replies
- Whether the mailbox’s
ExternalAudience is limited to known contacts
Get-RemoteDomain |
Format-Table Name,DomainName,AllowedOOFType,AutoReplyEnabled
Get-MailboxAutoReplyConfiguration [Email] |
Format-List AutoReplyState,ExternalAudience
A remote-domain setting can override the mailbox-level OOF configuration and block external replies.^1^
If neither internal nor external replies work
Ask the administrator to:
- Run a message trace for a fresh test message and its expected OOF response. For tracking the response, the original sender becomes the recipient.
- Check whether a transport rule blocked the response.
- Check the mailbox rules quota.
- Disable and re-enable OOF through Exchange Online PowerShell:
Set-MailboxAutoReplyConfiguration [Email] `
-AutoReplyState Disabled
Set-MailboxAutoReplyConfiguration [Email] `
-AutoReplyState Enabled
Corrupted OOF rule templates or an exceeded rules quota can prevent internal and external rules from being created.^3^
Deleting OOF rules with MFCMAPI should be a last resort. It permanently edits hidden mailbox data and Microsoft warns that incorrect use can damage mailbox contents. If forwarding, mail-flow, remote-domain, trace, and quota checks do not identify the issue, have the Microsoft 365 administrator open a support case rather than attempting MFCMAPI without an experienced Exchange administrator.
References
- Understanding and troubleshooting Out of Office (OOF) replies
- No out of office replies received from a mailbox that has automatic replies enabled
- The Out of Office feature in Outlook doesn't function correctly in Microsoft 365