The number for Authenticator number matching appears on the university app’s sign-in screen, while Authenticator should display a prompt where you enter or select that number.
Try the sign-in again
- Keep the university app or browser open at the screen displaying the number.
- Unlock your phone and manually open Microsoft Authenticator; do not rely only on a notification banner.
- Select your university account if a pending approval request is shown.
- Enter or select the number displayed by the university app, then approve the request.
If Authenticator contains only a rotating six-digit code, that is a different verification method; return to the university sign-in screen and select Sign in another way if that option is available.
If no approval request appears
Check these phone-side requirements:
- Authenticator → Settings → Notification Settings → Show notifications must be enabled.
- In the phone’s system settings, allow notifications for Authenticator and disable Do Not Disturb/Quiet mode.
- Unlock Authenticator—the entry box might not appear while the app is locked.
- Update Authenticator through the phone’s app store. Microsoft does not support Authenticator versions more than 12 months old.
- Set the phone’s date and time automatically.
- Switch from Wi-Fi to mobile data, or vice versa; temporarily disconnect any VPN.
- In Authenticator settings, select Turn off battery optimization if available.
These are Microsoft’s documented checks for missing authentication prompts and incomplete authentication.^1^^2^
Do not remove the university account from Authenticator unless you have another working sign-in method or your university IT team instructs you to do so; otherwise, you could lose the remaining registration.
If the prompt still never appears
Because this is a university-managed work or school account, contact the university’s IT help desk and ask them to require MFA re-registration for your account. This is especially relevant if you changed phones, restored Authenticator, or reinstalled the app.
An Authentication Administrator can perform the reset as follows:
- Open Microsoft Entra admin center.
- Go to Entra ID → Users.
- Select your account.
- Select Authentication methods.
- Select Require re-register MFA and confirm.
That action removes the existing Authenticator and related MFA methods, after which the next sign-in prompts you to register Authenticator again.^3^
Before contacting IT, Authenticator also lets you capture diagnostic information through its top-level menu under Send feedback. For work or school accounts, Microsoft directs users to their organization’s IT administrator after sending the logs.^1^
References
- [Personal accounts](https://support.microsoft.com/authenticator/troubleshoot-problems-with-microsoft-authenticator)
- Authentication did not complete | Microsoft Support
- Manage user authentication methods for Microsoft Entra multifactor authentication