A cloud-native solution that protects workloads across hybrid and multi-cloud environments with threat detection and security recommendations
Using Avast Free Antivirus is a legitimate choice, but use the current stable release—not a beta—for everyday protection, and do not expect Microsoft Defender Antivirus to remain fully active while Avast is registered as the primary antivirus.
Both Avast Free Antivirus and Microsoft Defender Antivirus were independently tested on Windows 11 in 2026; the available results do not establish that either product will catch every threat or that Avast is universally superior.^1^ ^2^
What happened when you selected “Allow”
Your observation is correct: Allow on device adds the detected file to Defender’s allowed list. Defender then stops taking action against that item in later scans. It does not mean the file was proven safe.^3^
If you allowed a file that may be infected:
- Open Windows Security.
- Select Virus & threat protection.
- Open Allowed threats.
- Expand the relevant detection and select Don’t allow.
- Do not open or run the file again.
“Don’t allow” removes the exception, allowing Defender to act the next time it encounters that file.^4^
The meanings of the other actions are:
- Quarantine: isolates the file so it cannot run.
- Remove: deletes the detected file.
- Threat blocked: Defender has already blocked and removed it; no further removal is required.
- Remediation incomplete: Defender attempted cleanup but could not finish. Expand the event for its required follow-up step.^5^
Protection History can also contain an old record even after the actual file has disappeared, so an entry by itself does not prove that malware is still active.
If Avast is currently installed
On ordinary Windows 10 or 11 PCs that are not onboarded to Microsoft Defender for Endpoint, installing and activating a compatible non-Microsoft antivirus causes Defender Antivirus to enter disabled mode automatically. This avoids two antivirus engines simultaneously providing active protection.^6^
Therefore:
- Keep Avast Free stable as the only primary real-time antivirus if it is working reliably.
- Do not judge Defender’s Remove button while Avast is the registered provider; Defender may no longer be the active remediation engine.
- Windows Security remains installed, but its Virus & threat protection page can display settings and status supplied by the third-party antivirus.
- If Avast is later uninstalled, Defender should turn itself back on automatically.^7^
Using Avast is not unfair to Microsoft. Antivirus choice should be based on reliability, usability, and protection—not loyalty to a vendor. Avoid beta security software on a primary PC unless deliberately testing it and prepared for defects.
If you want to return to Defender and clean up the allowed detection
Because you already tried several second-opinion scanners, repeating those scans is unlikely to clarify Defender’s own remediation state. Instead:
- Uninstall Avast and restart Windows.
- Open Windows Security → Virus & threat protection and verify that Microsoft Defender Antivirus is the active provider.
- Open Protection updates → Check for updates.
- Remove the item from Allowed threats as described above.
- Save all work, then select Scan options → Microsoft Defender Antivirus (offline scan) → Scan now.
The offline scan restarts the computer and scans in the Windows Recovery Environment, making it harder for persistent malware to hide or defend itself. Results appear afterward in Protection history.^8^
If Defender still reports Remediation incomplete or encounters an error while removing the item, run Windows Update and report the exact detection name, affected-file path, and error through Feedback Hub (Windows key + F). Microsoft’s troubleshooting guidance specifically recommends updates and Feedback Hub for repeated scanning or removal errors.^9^
Do not use a Farbar/FRST “fixlist” written for another computer. Such scripts are machine-specific and can cause damage when reused.^10^
References
- Test Avast Free Antivirus 26.4 & 26.5 for Windows 11 (261302) | AV-TEST
- Test Microsoft Defender Antivirus (Consumer) 4.18 for Windows 11 (261315) | AV-TEST
- Antivirus and antimalware software: FAQ | Microsoft Support
- Virus and Threat Protection in the Windows Security App | Microsoft Support
- Protection History in the Windows Security App | Microsoft Support
- Microsoft Defender Antivirus compatibility with other security products
- Windows Security App Overview | Microsoft Support
- Three easy steps to improve your cybersecurity | Microsoft Support
- Troubleshoot problems with detecting and removing malware | Microsoft Support
- My Windows Security shows a list of Threats that I can't remove, or fix. - Microsoft Q&A