External Collaboration and Conditional Access, Require Strong MFA

Smith, Rudolph 11 Reputation points
2026-11-18T14:02:43.7866667+00:00

Looking for recommended best practice. We have external users invited as guests to collaborate with our employees in SharePoint. we have recently come across a scenario where the guest users are on a MacOS device and utilizing OKTA for their MFA authentication. This is causing an issue with our Conditional Access policy requiring authentication strength with Strong MFA Authentication selected.

Scenario:

External user clicks the link for our SharePoint site, it prompts them to login with their username and OKTA MFA. This then throws the "you cannot reach this site" error because it is failing our MFA CA.

I have read that I would need to setup an organizational trust. My only concerns with this is I cannot control which users from their tenant can access SharePoint. I have to either enable for all of their users OR they control it with user IDs/group IDs provided to me for permission.

Microsoft Security | Microsoft Entra | Microsoft Entra External ID
0 comments No comments

1 answer

Sort by: Newest
  1. AI answer

    2026-11-18T14:03:41.4933333+00:00

    Configure organization-specific inbound MFA trust for the partner tenant only if its Okta flow is federated through Microsoft Entra ID and produces an Entra MFA claim; this does not grant every partner user access to SharePoint.

    1. In the Microsoft Entra admin center, go to Entra ID → External Identities → Cross-tenant access settings → Organizational settings.
    2. Add the partner using its full domain or tenant ID.
    3. Open the partner’s Inbound access settings and select Customize settings.
    4. On Trust settings, enable Trust multifactor authentication from Microsoft Entra tenants, then save.

    With this setting, your Conditional Access policy still applies. Entra accepts the partner’s MFA only when the authentication session contains a valid claim that MFA was completed in the home tenant; otherwise, another MFA challenge is issued. Configure this per partner rather than changing the default trust for every organization.^1^

    Microsoft recommends trusting a partner’s MFA claims only when there is a close business relationship and its MFA practices have been verified.^2^

    Trust does not give all partner users SharePoint access

    There are separate authorization layers:

    • MFA trust decides whether your Conditional Access policy accepts the MFA performed in the partner tenant.
    • Inbound B2B access settings decide which partner users/groups and applications can participate.
    • SharePoint permissions decide who can open the site, library, folder, or file.

    Therefore, enabling MFA trust does not automatically provision users or grant SharePoint permissions. Only guests who have been invited and assigned the relevant SharePoint permission can access the content.

    If you also want to restrict which identities from that tenant are eligible for inbound B2B access:

    1. In the same partner-specific Inbound access configuration, open B2B collaboration.
    2. Under External users and groups, choose Allow access.
    3. Under Applies to, select Select external users and groups.
    4. Enter the partner’s user or group object IDs.
    5. On Applications, restrict access to the required applications if appropriate.

    Selecting specific external users or groups requires Microsoft Entra ID P1 or P2, and the partner must supply its object IDs. Organization-specific settings override your defaults.^1^

    If obtaining and maintaining partner object IDs is impractical, leave inbound B2B eligibility broader and control actual access through guest invitations, SharePoint site membership, groups, and sharing permissions.

    Confirm which Okta integration is involved

    “Okta MFA” can represent different authentication paths, and they do not have the same Conditional Access support.

    Okta federates the partner’s Microsoft Entra sign-in

    MFA trust can work when the guest is an external Microsoft Entra user and the resulting home-tenant session contains an MFA claim. The claimed method must also satisfy the authentication strength required by your policy. If the claim is absent or insufficient, Entra challenges the user again or blocks access.^3^

    Okta is an Entra external authentication method

    External authentication methods are currently incompatible with the Require authentication strength grant control. In that case, change the guest policy’s grant control to Require multifactor authentication, rather than Require authentication strength.^4^

    Guest does not authenticate through Microsoft Entra ID

    Authentication-strength policies apply only to external users authenticating with Microsoft Entra ID. For SAML/WS-Fed, Google federation, email one-time passcode, and Microsoft personal accounts, use the Require multifactor authentication grant control instead.^5^

    Validate before changing enforcement

    For an affected sign-in:

    1. Go to Entra ID → Monitoring & health → Sign-in logs.
    2. Open the failed SharePoint sign-in.
    3. On Authentication Details, review the authentication method, MFA result, and the authentication-strength requirement.
    4. On Conditional Access, open the failed policy and inspect its Grant Controls.

    These details show whether the home tenant supplied an MFA claim, whether the required authentication strength was evaluated, and which policy blocked access.^6^

    Test the partner-specific trust and any revised Conditional Access policy in Report-only first. Exclude emergency-access accounts before enabling the policy.^4^


    References

    1. Manage cross-tenant access settings for B2B collaboration
    2. Microsoft Entra B2B best practices
    3. How Conditional Access authentication strengths work for external users
    4. Require multifactor authentication strength for external users
    5. Authentication and Conditional Access for External ID
    6. Troubleshoot Conditional Access authentication strengths
    AI-generated content may be incorrect. Read our transparency notes for more information.

    Was this answer helpful?

Your answer

Answers can be marked as 'Accepted' by the question author and 'Recommended' by moderators, which helps users know the answer solved the author's problem.