Entire domain incrediblecompany.de flagged as High Confidence Phish by EOP/Outlook.com - false positive, need escalation

Nis Lehmann-Matthaei 0 Reputation points
2026-11-15T13:41:48.7+00:00

Since 29 Oct 2026, every email that contains any URL of our domain incrediblecompany.de is quarantined as "High confidence phish" in Microsoft 365 tenants and goes to Junk (SCL 9) at Outlook.com.

What we tested (15 Nov 2026):

Test 1: Same message without our URL: delivered to inbox.

Test 2: Plain email from an unrelated free-mail provider containing only a link to www.incrediblecompany.de: quarantined / Junk.

Test 3: Plain email with a link to a NON-EXISTENT subdomain of our domain (no DNS record): quarantined / Junk.

So the verdict is attached to the whole registered domain, independent of sender, IP or authentication (SPF/DKIM/DMARC pass).

Microsoft's own submission analysis: the quarantined email was resolved as "No threats found", the two URL submissions as "Unknown - we checked but can't make a decision right now". The block is still active.

The domain is our company website and B2B wholesale shop (cosmetics, Germany). Google Safe Browsing, Norton, Cisco Talos and VirusTotal (0/92) show it as clean.

Already done: Defender admin URL submissions, email submission from quarantine, a Microsoft Security Intelligence (WDSI) submission, an open Microsoft 365 support case and an Outlook.com sender support case. Case numbers available on request.

This affects our business email to all Microsoft-hosted customers. Can someone from Microsoft help escalate this to the team that maintains domain/URL reputation for EOP and Outlook.com?

Microsoft Security | Microsoft Defender | Microsoft Defender for Office 365

Your answer

Answers can be marked as 'Accepted' by the question author and 'Recommended' by moderators, which helps users know the answer solved the author's problem.