Hello Cris Williams,
Thank you for posting question on Microsoft Windows Forum!
The plausible explanation to this behavior is that profile state machine mismatch during the initial Service Discovery Protocol (SDP) query and link establishment upon a cold boot. When Windows initializes the connection to the AirPods Pro 3 on startup, it successfully negotiates the A2DP (Advanced Audio Distribution Profile) sink for high-quality music/media output. However, the handshake or SDP attribute request for the HFP/HSP (Hands-Free Profile / Audio Gateway) service times out or fails to bind the eSCO (Synchronous Connection-Oriented) voice channel required for the microphone. Windows treats the device strictly as an output-only audio sink.
When you disconnect and reconnect, the AirPods' internal firmware state machine and the Windows Bluetooth stack force a fresh SDP re-enumeration. On this second attempt, the Hands-Free profile successfully registers, exposing both the playback endpoint and the mic input.
The suggestion here is to check "Hands-Free Telephony" service which can sometimes be disabled or fail to stick, preventing the microphone profile from loading. In the Devices and Printers console. Right-click your AirPods Pro 3 and select Properties. Go to the Services tab. Ensure Hands-Free Telephony is checked. If it is unchecked, enable it, click Apply, and reconnect the AirPods.
Since Windows frequently puts Bluetooth host controllers into low-power states during boot or modern standby, causing radio state corruption when audio profiles try to initialize simultaneously. It is worth disabling Power Management on the Bluetooth Adapter by opening Device Manager. Expand Bluetooth, right-click your primary Bluetooth adapter, and select Properties. Navigate to the Power Management tab. Then uncheck "Allow the computer to turn off this device to save power". Also, making sure the Startup type of these services Windows Audio, Windows Audio Endpoint Builder, and Bluetooth Support Service are set to Automatic, and right-click -> Restart them if you notice audio subsystem hangups.
Otherwise, you can consider to uninstall your physical Bluetooth adapter and then perform a clean Bluetooth adapter reinstall.
If the provided information is helpful! It is appreciated to consider clicking "Accept Answer". Should you have more questions, feel free to leave a message. Have a nice working day!