Had this same issue as well. Using Vivetool did not work, as previously mentioned above. I eventually uninstalled the October 2026 preview update, which reverted back to the new loading circle.
Then I found this article on neowin.net while looking for an updated solution.
Microsoft rolls back a Windows 11 design change with latest build but says it's temporary
Under the Windows design section...
We are temporarily rolling back the solid (donut) spinners across some of the key Windows scenarios including Boot, Logon, Restart, Shutdown, and Update as we work on a bug. We expect to resume rolling it out soon.
No explanation as to what the bug is, but I haven't seen anything suspicious across several Windows 11 machines running the latest build. Hopefully this will be addressed by the time the October 2026 preview update is officially ready to be rolled out.