Hi Tamiaus Nalls,
Thanks for confirming that you changed the boot order and created the recovery drive. Have you completed all the steps in the AI Answer above? If so, please let me know how it went and what happens when you try to boot from the USB. Does the Surface return to Windows, remain on the Surface logo, reopen UEFI or display an error?
Also, does USB Storage appear under Surface UEFI > Boot configuration? If it appears, try swiping left on USB Storage to start a one-time boot.
If that does not work, test with a different USB drive. If you are using a USB-A-to-USB-C adapter, try another adapter or connect a USB-C flash drive directly. You can also check whether the recovery drive is detected normally on another computer.
If the Surface cannot detect two correctly prepared recovery drives through different connections, the next step would be to contact Surface Support for further assessment.