Hello Drago,
The situation you’re describing is a common consequence of hardware replacement, particularly when the motherboard is swapped. BitLocker recovery keys are bound to the TPM and hardware ID of the original device. Once the mainboard is replaced, the system generates a new hardware ID, which means the recovery key stored in Azure AD or Active Directory is associated with the old device object. If that object has been disabled, the keys remain tied to it and are not automatically migrated to the new device record.
To answer your question directly: yes, the old device record can typically be re-enabled in Azure AD or Active Directory. Once re-enabled, you should be able to access the BitLocker recovery keys from the device’s properties in the portal. In Azure AD, navigate to Azure Active Directory > Devices > All devices, locate the disabled device, and re-enable it. After that, open the device details and check the BitLocker keys section. The recovery key should still be present there, as disabling a device does not delete its stored recovery information. If you are using on-premises Active Directory with MBAM or Group Policy escrow, the same principle applies: re-enable the computer object in AD Users and Computers, then check the BitLocker Recovery tab.
If re-enabling is not possible due to policy restrictions, the only other way to retrieve the recovery key is from the original escrow location where it was stored at encryption time. This could be Azure AD, AD DS, or the user’s Microsoft account if self-service was enabled. Without access to that escrowed key, there is no supported method to bypass BitLocker protection. Microsoft’s security model does not allow recovery keys to be regenerated or transferred between hardware IDs.
In short: request your IT team to re-enable the old device object in Azure AD or AD DS. Once that’s done, you should be able to retrieve the BitLocker recovery key from the device record. If the object was deleted rather than disabled, then unfortunately the recovery key is permanently lost unless it was backed up elsewhere.
I hope you've found something useful here. If it helps you get more insight into the issue, it's appreciated to accept the answer. Should you have more questions, feel free to leave a message. Have a nice day!HP.